North Macedonia exhibits a relatively modest level of rule-of-law resilience, characterised by the coexistence of important resilience resources and persistent structural vulnerabilities.
Although the country has experienced severe political crises and episodes of democratic backsliding over the past decade, these have not resulted in the abandonment of constitutional governance or democratic competition. However, these resilience resources have not been sufficient to overcome long-standing weaknesses in institutional performance, accountability and the implementation of reforms.
Regime legitimation is the country’s strongest primary resilience resource. Despite political polarisation and contested institutional decisions, political actors have continued to justify their actions through constitutional procedures, parliamentary processes, elections and legal arguments, reinforcing the constitutional framework as the accepted arena for political competition. Civil society – supported by a comparatively strong community of researchers, universities and policy institutes – has also played an important role in sustaining public scrutiny when formal oversight institutions have been less effective.
Resilience continues to be constrained by the persistence of clientelist governance. Corruption, political influence over public institutions, weak implementation of reforms and limited administrative autonomy reflect deeper structural patterns that undermine the effectiveness of the rule of law – particularly in corruption control, regulatory enforcement, judicial effectiveness and constraints on government power. Although EU conditionality has reinforced constitutional governance and institutional reform, its transformative influence has weakened as enlargement has become shaped by bilateral disputes and geopolitical considerations.
North Macedonia demonstrates that rule-of-law resilience should not just be equated with institutional effectiveness. Democratic systems can remain resilient despite weak institutional performance – when political authority continues to be exercised and contested through constitutional procedures and when independent societal actors retain the capacity to monitor power and sustain public accountability.
But this resilience has clear limits; the future trajectory of rule-of-law resilience in North Macedonia will depend less on the creation of new formal institutions than on the capacity to ensure that existing institutions operate with greater autonomy, accountability and effectiveness. Without sustained progress in addressing the underlying structures of clientelism and strengthening institutional autonomy, resilience risks being reduced to the mere capacity to preserve democratic continuity – rather than the capacity to achieve substantive improvements in the quality of governance.
Read the report:
RESILIO-ACCESS Country Report ‒ North Macedonia
About the project: RESILIO-ACCESS investigates the resilience of the rule of law in the current (potential) candidate countries for EU accession. The project explores how to measure resilience and how to assess the potential of the EU’s enlargement policy toolbox to foster sustainable resilience in the region. Resilience here means the capacity of the rule of law to prevent, cope with, or recover from hazardous events or incremental threats – without losing its core function, structure, and purpose.
About the paper: This paper is part of the RESILIO-ACCESS Country Reports, a collection of compact analyses that assess the source of rule of law resilience in EU aspirant countries by using the analytical framework of the RESILIO-ACCESS model.
The RESILIO-ACCESS model is based on three dimensions: The system of the rule of law itself provides primary resilience resources such as an effective judicial system, the protection of fundamental rights, and democratic elections. These resources are embedded into a social environment with subsidiary resilience resources such as civil society, academia, and the media. However, these resources are constantly being challenged by threats such as autocracy, corruption, violence, or censorship.
The characteristics of each dimension, their interactions, and their conditions of resilience resources determine the overall resilience capacity of the rule of law.
RESILIO-ACCESS is funded by Stiftung Mercator. The project is implemented by Institut für Europäische Politik in Berlin and the Institute for Democracy “Societas Civilis” in Skopje. For more information, visit the project website.









